Monday, February 8, 2010

My comments on an article in "Indian Express"

On Saturday 6/2/2010 a thought provoking article about family came in the Indian express by Ashley Tellis. Click here for this article.

In response to this, there came an article from Sushil K. (Asst. Editor). Click here for article.

I did not like this response much so I wrote him a mail (cc to Ashley Tellis). You will like it more if you go through the above articles first. Here goes my email-

Hello Sir,

I am a regular reader of Indian express and I also read the Ashley Tellis article about family on 6/2/2010and your take on that today 7/2/2010. I am in much more agreement with Tellis rather than you.Moreover your response to his article is very weak. Tellis has raised many questions about the family but you have responded to only one or two of his points, and that too not very convincing. You think that Tellis lives in a perpetual state of hate(you even generalised this to all gays but on what basis ?)but I can tell you he do not. He not even hates his parents. He is actually"Living in a greater state of awareness than you and most of the people in this country". I have no personal access to Tellis, I have never emailed him earlier, I am saying this based on my opinion formed by reading his articles every weak, and I am great fan of him.Because he is among the very few truth speaking people in this country, unlike you the "Politically correct" lot. Your only argument is that when a family comes to know about a gay member, it is equally shocking to them as well so their rejection of this is understandable. Tellis has written in his first line that "My family did not value Love ..."Now what is the meaning of Love for you. Love means 'unconditional Love', and that is not the case with most of the Indian families.The amount of love you receive in a family is directly proportional to your capabilities(e.g. your earnings) and your submission to family orders.Have you seen "Taare zameen par" ? Do I need to tell you why Eeshan awasthi did not receive as much love as his elder brother from his family ? Do I need to tell you why he faced rejection everywhere in family and school ? Do I need to tell you why lots and lots of people have cried after watching the movie including Aamir Khan ?Do I need to tell you this is the scenario in most of the families ?You may be part of an unconditional love family , but most people are not. You are an editor of national newspaper but you have very poor observation of your surroundings. I have lived in Chennai, in comparison to north India, far more women go out and do jobs, but the way a man treats his wife or daughter is as pathetic as all over India. In today's paper there is a survey about women in Kerela(on front page).They are all suffering because of this "Great family Love". In yesterday's paper (6/2/2010) there is a news about a 16 year old girl in Turkey, buried alive by her family. Her father and grand father are in custody now. Now I don't need to tell you that this kind of great show of love by family happens in India also. Tellis has raised this issue by saying "Heterosexual children are not allowed to choose their own partners, taken to court on habeas corpus, beaten, imprisoned, killed, accused of abduction and kidnapping, hung in the town square by their family". But you do not say anything about it. I think you don't even read the paper properly.I give you one example. If a young girl in any part of this country declares to her parents that she is in love with a lower cast man and want to marry him(say a tamil brahmin girl in love with a north India SC). Now what will be the response of her family. Obviously it will be rejection first. There will be very few families who will ultimately give in for the sake of love of their daughter and accept the relationship but most of the families will never accept this and may even kill their daughter. The first category of the family is the "unconditional love".Unfortunately they are very few. You say about Tellis that "He forgets that not just 'he' but his very 'gayness' is a product of that "private ownership" of sexual reproducibility inherent in the family". Are you trying to suggest that you have no right to criticize your family values ?If someone is born in a terrorist family then should he not criticize terrorism ?Overall, I just want to say that you should come up with stronger stuff, because I like Indian Express and you write in that. -

Regards

Jitendra

As expected I have not received any response from Sushil K. , surprisingly I got response from

Ashley Tellis(In fact I should not be surprised. Truthful people have nothing to hide). Here goes the response -

Dear Mr. Dimri,

Thank you for your email.Thank you for being able to see that the point is not about individual families but the family as an institution.You are right to point out that the family is not base on unconditional love even when it claims to be and that is assesses and values people in crass terms. Think also of how families treat the girl child in relation to the boy. The other gender realities you point out yourself.Your Taare Zameen Par example is a good one in relation to how the family treats him but also, in the long run, a problematic one. The only problem with that film is that in the end, after claiming that ‘every child is special’, it recuperates the dyslexic child into the grand narrative of success and achievement, after which the family (and the school) accept him. I found the film anti-child and anti-disability.When Mr. sushil says I am a product of the family, he may b facually wrong and there are many millions of people born outside the family. Because people are born in the family, that makes the family okay? Your terrorism example is a good one and I think the family is a terrorist institution, actually. It terrorises people, especially women and children. The family is the real terrorist in our country and the world.Thank you once again for your letter and I hope you think of writing for the NIE.

BestAshley

PS: I’m sending you a copy of the response I sent to the paper to Mr. Sushil. I am not sure if they will carry it so I wanted you to read it

And here is what Tellis(Thank you for sending this to me) wrote as response to Sushil K. for his article -


Sushil K T’s response to my article was so naïve as perhaps not to deserve a response. He spends the first almost half of it speculating mindlessly on my biography when the whole point of my article was that one can multiply examples of ‘good’ and ‘bad’ families ad infinitum but the basic structural critique of the family remains. He has no answer to that structural critique so instead he offers cheap biographical accounts of reverse family trauma when he knows nothing about my family.
But let us try and make some axiomatic sense of what he is saying. So, he is saying that we must understand the ‘horror’ and the ‘trauma’ of parents of have gay children. Why? What is this understanding based on if not the implicit assumption that heterosexual is right and homosexual is wrong? With what authority does Mr Sushil speak for “everyone on the planet”? My article was in response to one that appeared the previous week (by Aniruddh Vasudevan) who portrayed an extraordinary family (his own) accepting love of all its members as a basic principle. So, Sushil is, simply, first and foremost, factually incorrect and making a universal principle out of a personal prejudice.
Suresh is intellectually incapable of seeing that the point is not about his family or mine but about the institution of family. He also knows nothing about the gay movement if he thinks what we want is to be accepted as normal. What we are, in fact, saying, is that the very concept of normal is to be questioned and done away with.
By not seeing the family as an institution, Suresh shows his mind is full of wet mud and no clarity at all. His last eugenic fantasy only shows the utterly dangerous stupidity of the man. As for hatred, I am proud to be full of hatred. Hatred can be very productive and useful. As B. R Ambedkar put it: “I want to tell my critics that I regard my feelings of hatred as a real force. They are the only reflex of the love I bear for the causes I believe in and I am in no way ashamed of it.”

Tuesday, January 12, 2010

Joint family is flawed institution

I do not call Joint family 'highly flawed' because it is not a hopeless case like arranged marriage. There are many good features of joint family but overall drawbacks are more. In any book of social science you can find these drawbacks listed there. I have nothing new to add to that list but I want to highlight some of them because my basic intention is to criticize one aspect of constitutional structure of India. When I thought about this aspect then I came to conclusion that widespread appreciation and practice of joint family is responsible for this.
So, I will start with problems of joint family. It is a socialistic structure. One person is head of the family and he controls everything. In joint family some people work a lot and some do not work at all but they all get same benefits. This breeds inefficiency. Controlling is the main problem of this institution. If control is weak then family will break, so a strong control on all the family activities is required. Controlling works against the personal development of most of the family members. It benefits one or two members only (many times the youngest member of the family as he is loved by all). Controlling kills the personal freedom which is needed for creative thinking. All these drawbacks you can find in detail in any social science book but still, I don't know why, people keep on appreciating this institution. Our hero in the hindi movies always advises the public not to break the family. Political and spiritual leaders keep on giving sermons in the favor of joint family. I want to simply say that all of them are backward looking and unscientific people.
Now I come to the main issue, constitutional structure of India. When India became independent, the makers of constitution considered joint family as holy cow and gave us the constitution of India. What is the problem with the constitution, it is the "Control". As in joint family there is a very strong head of the family we have a very strong central government. As in joint family, the members have very little say in crucial matters our state governments are powerless and resource less. Most of the states are functioning inefficiently and only few are working well. Today there are demands for many new states because people are fed up with inefficiency. Just making new states is not enough as we know they do not have power to function independently. We have lost a huge opportunity with 60 years of independence. India should have been a much more developed country by now, at least more developed than China.
America like constitution would have been much better for India. In USA the central government has only two things foreign policy and defense. Rest all is with state governments. In India our central government is running 5 star hotels and a junk, huge loss making airline named 'Air India'. They are doing hell lot of other loss making businesses so they do not have time for the most important thing , the defense of country. That is why we see terrorist activities happening at regular intervals. China is eating up our lands at border slowly. And there is no one to blame. When a farmer does suicide in Vidarbha the Prime minister is blamed in parliament. I think, like USA, our central govt. also should restrict itself with defense and foreign policy. Finance, HRD, Agriculture etc. all the ministries should be removed from centre. Indian railway is related to defense so that should remain with centre.
If we don't do this, many other countries (like China, Israel in the past 60 years ) will march ahead of India in the coming 60 years. We will remain many years behind them and will give them sermons on benefits of joint family.

Tuesday, December 8, 2009

Arranged marriage is highly flawed institution - 2

Recently I read the book "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus" by John Gray. This book is a must read for every man and woman, who are or planning to be, in a relationship. This book highlights how poor our understanding is of opposite sex. Now this book is written by an American and as we know America is a very open society as compared to us when it comes to communication between men and women. Still American people have less understanding of opposite sex, you can imagine in what great abyss we Indian people are.
So , continuing from my last article, how arrange marriage promotes lack of interaction. We all want to interact with opposite sex but still we follow the restrictions of our society and elders. Why we do not revolt against this ? Its simple, because arrange marriage is easy way out. If we have to look for a good girl for ourselves it is hard work. Where you can't even interact with a women it is almost impossible. So we take the lollipop(arrange marriage) from our elders, simple. You may be the most unattractive man with most deriding opinion about women , still you can get the brightest and the prettiest woman for you if you are powerful, or have money or good job, by arrange marriage. For the women it is like sleeping with the enemy. Arranged marriage is highly tilted towards men, power and money(dowry). It is highly undemocratic because it kills our freedom to choose.
Arranged marriage is tool in the hands of our society to control younger people. Yes younger people should be controlled but by moral principles, and not at the cost of freedom. Parents want arranged marriage so that they have better control of the lives of their kids. But this controlling comes at the cost of happiness. Neither husband wife are happy with each other nor their parents are happy with them. It is not that parents want to do this for the welfare of their kids. If that is the case why they disown or even ready to kill their own kids when kids marry by their own choice. Sometimes people say I am doing arrange marriage by my own choice, but saying this is illogical. It is something like a women wearing Burqa saying that it is my choice, or Sachin Tendualkar saying that I wear helmet by my choice to face fast bowlers. Sunil Gavaskar made his choice and wore a cap and faced the most lethal pace attack of West-Indies bowlers. A choice means you have other options also.
There are other social issues promoted and protected by arranged marriage like dowry, castism, racism, regionalism, women discrimination, child abuse etc. We can not outrightly reject this institution because at present for most of the people this is the only way to get married. The first step towards removing this very bad institution is to stop men, women segregation. There should be no non co-education school. Men and women should be segregated only at places of extreme difficulties like local bus or Mumbai local train, otherwise not. I don't see these things happenning in near future. I finish this article by just saying one thing that I am sure, I'll not impose my rule over my child or any other child.

Thursday, October 22, 2009

Arranged marriage is highly flawed institution - 1

In our society interaction of young men and women is restricted. If I look back at my life, my interactions with women are very few and far apart and none of them were of the level where you develop an understanding with other person. I have always been to a non co-Education school. Then I did engineering that too in mechanical. Very few women go for engineering and none of them opts for mechanical. After that now I am working in IT industry but in mechanical domain where women to men ratio is normally 1:25 or worse. Sometimes I think am I living in a Islamic society like Iran, Iraq or Afghanistan, where women are separated from men. Frankly speaking our Indian society is a miniature version of Talibani society. We can see the manifestation of this in our movies. In Hindi movies a villain or sometime hero treats a woman badly and in South Indian movies all heroes treat women very badly. You will say , come on! you can talk to any woman in India. Yes I know that but there are practical problems because of our social structure, some of them I have mentioned above.
The worst consequence of all this is that, we treat women badly and we are never aware of that. Like we have seen the video of a Taliban man whipping a woman on her buttocks. That man treated the woman so badly but in his mind he was doing right thing. Its all about level of awareness. We condemn that act but we also do many wrong things to woman and think that we are doing right. Our level of awareness is not adequate and that is because of lack of interaction with women. Of course people who go to co-ed and have better environment where men women ratio is good , behave better with women. I have had interactions with such guys from the time of my engineering. Their understanding of women was far better than me. I was an absolute dumb when it came to women. My idea of dealing with woman was following the filmy heroes. Today i know that how bad this idea is to follow Indian filmy hero. It is like "Apne pair main Kulhadi marna". Today I am married for 3 years and with my understanding I can say that the better guys at the time of my engineering were also very poor when it come to women. The point I want to make here is that even if someone comes form a co-ed his understanding of women remains at a very low level because there are no(or very few) deep interactions among boys and girls. The reason for that is we are not allowed. If you are seen with a girl too much then questions will be raised. I think we are all aware of such practical problems. After 3 years of marriage and interactions with my wife I think I am much improved person to deal with a woman. I Imagine, how good I would have become if I would have interacted deeply with say 10 women. I am sure I would have been a much much better person. This not only makes you better to deal with women it makes you overall a better person. But now the tragedy is that half of the life is over and that too the better one. We have lost the joyous part of our life unaware. We can never get back the energy and enthusiasm of a 20 year old.
So finally I come to the main point of this article. In the societies like ours to interact deeply with a woman you have to marry. This is an absolutely absurd scenario but this is reality of our India. The first problem is that you do not get chance to interact with many women as you can marry only one woman legally. I don't want to marry 10 women but I certainly want to interact with hundreds of women. A marriage in which you are allowed to interact freely with your partner only after marriage is called "Arranged Marriage".
If you go around and ask people that do they like arranged marriage, majority answer will be positive. In my opinion this is "Absurd Marriage" as I have made my point above. Arranged marriage actually promotes lack of interaction. If there is free communication there will be no arrange marriage. This is just beginning I have lot of other stuff against this holy institution. I'll come up with that later. I'll first argue that how arranged marriage promotes lack of interaction between men and women. Any comments 'for or against' are welcome.

Tuesday, August 11, 2009

The twisted Indian morality

Now days a show called "Sach ka Saamna" is going on , on starplus. It is the Indian version of the US show "Moment of Truth". I had seen some episodes of this US show when Indian counterpart was not there. At that time I use to think that this show can never come to India, as India is a country of hypocrites and timid people, so no one will come to say the dark truths about his life. Moreover if it comes to India it will certainly be opposed and banned by our moral leaders.
I was pleasantly surprised to see the Indian show "Sach ka Saamna" and people revealing there secrets. I was very happy that there are courageous and truthful people in India. But I also felt very bad when my second doubt came true. Few days back in our parliament, some of our MPs(Member of Parliament) raised the issue of this show and demanded to ban it. They said the questions being asked in the show are against Indian morality. Congress party minister Ambika Soni immediately obliged the MPs by sending a notice to the TV channel. Thankfully the TV show is not banned but they display a warning message during the show, and now its timing have been changed from 10:30 pm to 11 pm in the night. But what are the questions which our MPs think are against our morality. The media reports did not elaborate on that but it is very easy to figure out that the question regarding physical relations and other sex related questions are the culprits.
Now my question is what is a bigger crime adultery or robbery. According to Indian mentality and our parliamentarians metality adultery is a bigger crime than robbery. Thats why I am calling it twisted morality. Now I will prove my point that our MPs are more worried about adultery than robbery. Now days there is a commercial of Bajaj bike going on, in which the hero with the bike easily robs a Bank and gets away in his bike. Now why our MPs did not bother about this TV commercial. This is trying to teach our youngsters that with this new bike you can easily do a robbery. Its simple, because they think that this is not as serious a crime as talking about sex or doing adultery. And if a women commits adultery then that is limit. There is no bigger crime than this, even murder is small in comparison to this. Every now and then we get news that a family killed its daughter because she ran away with some guy. Recently this type of news came from a village in Haryana. Then our MPs give lecture in the parliament that people should not take law into their own hands.
The conclusion is that there is no difference between the mentality of people who are killing their daughters and sisters for adultery and these MPs who are raising opposition to the TV show "Sach ka Saamna". And the most sad part about it is that there was no other MP to oppose this third class mentality. (atleast I did not see any media report about that.)

Tuesday, July 28, 2009

Income tax system of India

As usual, July 31st is the last date of filing the Income tax returns. Most of the working class people including me, are busy again to finish this yearly duty. Every time I do this exercise and I feel frustrated. Why do all these junk works like get proof of your investments, get different types of receipts etc. Every year we have to do this because it will save us crucial money in the form of tax exemption. The whole tax system is quite complex. On my own I have never been able to find out my tax liability(Although I am in good Mathematics, as I have done masters in Mechanical Engineering). Because there is this clause and there is that clause. Last year I paid some 500 rupees to some guy to file my income tax returns. This year I got someone who charged only 150.
The point I am trying to make is when things are complex then things become corrupt. I f we make things simple then there will very less possibility of corruption. It will save a huge amount of time, money and energy of all the people. First the government imposes a tax then they give some exemption. These exemptions are the root of all corruption. For salaried people there is not much scope in the sense that they can not abuse these exemptions for great benefits. But for business people there is unlimited scope. One can learn from Ramalinga Raju how things can be manipulated even in a big public company.
The income tax for salaried people can be simplified very easily. There should be no clause for any exemption. There should be some flat tax rates for different level of income like we have billing of electricity. This will not only make life easy of a tax payer but also of the employer and of the government also.
Even when we have an economist Prime Minister and honest too, we can not expect this happening in near future. After all this a congress government, who are the creators of all these corrupt systems and socialistic mentality.

Monday, April 20, 2009

Legacy of Nehru

Recently Prime Minister Manmohan Singh said that the only achievement of Advani in his political life, is the Babri masjid demolition. He is in election campaign so he is pointing out negatives of his opponent. Let us do the same thing with the Nehru, the first Prime minister of India. What is the achievement of Nehru. The humiliation of 1962 or tilting Indian policy towards communism or creator of dynastic politics in India.
Advani may not be fully responsible for Babri masjid demolition but Nehru is the only reason of 1962 defeat of India at the hands of China. He adopted a "No defense against China" policy. Because China was good friend of Him. He gave the Permanent seat at the UN security council to China. He did not allocate enough budget for preparing the army for any possible threat against China. Many world leaders at that time warned Nehru that China is planning attack on India. And when finally China attacked the whole world laughed at India. That is why it was not just a defeat at war for India but a humiliation.
Now the second achievement. What is wrong in having your policies tilted towards communism. The very simple answer is communism breeds dictatorship and corruption. We just need to see around the world and at communist states and it becomes quite obvious. See USSR, China, Cuba, Venezuela etc. As India was not absolute communist state , so there was no absolute dictatorship also. But there was Some amount of dictatorship during the times of Indira Gandhi. And corruption is there for everyone to see. This tilt has caused a huge loss to India in terms of foreign policy. Because of our "Non-Aligned Movement" most of the capitalistic world powers see India skeptically. We have lost the benefits of good relations with world powers.
The third achievement of Nehru the dynastic politics. It is being followed by the leaders in this country in almost all the states. We have leaders and then we have their wives, their sons their daughters. If you are not in the family then you have a very little scope of growing in politics.

With so many achievements in the name of Nehru, I think Advani is better than Nehru.